Forums

Note: This forum is not affiliated with World Sailing and comments on this forum do not represent an official interpretation of the rules, definitions, cases or regulations. The only official interpretations are those of World Sailing.

Powered by WIND


Recent Posts

Recent Comments

  • Maybe the standard shouldn't change, but I think that in practice, it inevitably will change.

    Consider a ILCA national championships.  Mid fleet, while not showing the superb boat handling of Robert Sheidt, or Brett Beyer, boats will consistently be making tactical crosses inside significantly less than half a metre, and reasonable apprehension will tend towards that level of skill.

    Now think about a bunch of sailing school Fevas, and reasonable apprehension will be considerably broader.

     The reasonableness test, at the end of the day, however we moderate and qualify it, depends on the judgement and opinions of the protest committee.
    As Michael Butterfield said

    ...  the better the jury the better the decision generally. 

    Experienced judges will be able to 'dial down' the skill level they consider reasonable.

    Today 13:37
  • A holywood is really a match racing term for a great show, but may not be genuine.
    Yesterday 20:58
  • @Lars - having done a number of WASZP events, I found the RRS 42 rules easy to see and enforce.
    Yesterday 16:45
  • The world sailing judges manual changes on improper act or ommission in each version, each seeming giving judges more room for interpretation. Just track the change next time, it may be what gordon and i may expect.
    The old bad race management hidden behind the word may not shall,, may not be tolerated.
    A time of change perhaps! I believe for the better if we are to improve standards and improve the sport.
  • To me once a boat had done a 44.2 set of turns, they have not initially finished and there can be no other score but the last finish.

    Other rule breaches are something else which really should be protested by boats.

    There is no reason for a rc to act if they score the finish after the turns.
    26-Apr-23 12:27
Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn more