• RRS 70.3(b) - Denial of right to appeal (conditional)
  13 Comments
  Benjamin Harding Yesterday 01:10
• To be a MARK or not to be
  6 Comments
  Catalan Benaros 26-Feb-11 21:57
• On-the-water "3-minute Justice" NOR/SI/Appendix?
  10 Comments
  Angelo Guarino 26-Feb-10 12:11
• Rule 18.2(d)
  17 Comments
  Rene Nusse 26-Feb-10 03:16
• New MNA Prescription Link to WS Website on RRoS
  0 Comments
  Angelo Guarino 26-Feb-07 01:37

• RRS 70.3(b) - Denial of right to appeal (conditional)
  An OA has no decision to make or action to take under RRS 70.1.
  
  Do you mean MNA?
  
  Appeals frequently fail because they seek to dispute facts found.
  
  Case 104 discusses the difference between facts and conclusions.
  
  A protest committee can't hide by putting a conclusion under the Facts Found heading
  
  In the context of a protest committee's written decision i would suggest that a conclusion involves applying one or more rules to a set of facts.
  John Allan Today 01:31
• Mark-Room and Room to Pass an Obstruction who wins.
  See John's response.   For the sake of simplicity, if we ask for an interpretation, the testimony of both competitors is that was only room for one boat to pass safely between the mark and the obstruction.
  
  Further. What happens if there are three boats overlapped? I was recently on a one-design start line with 103 boats.  I wish I could tell you that I had a fantastic first leg and arrived at the top mark in the top 3 boats with no overlap. Alas by the time I got there, so did a lot of other boats.  Fortunately, no obstruction. But I confess that Mark's Xmas puzzler was going through my head as I rounded 3 abreast.
  
  Oh, and I had a much better downwind leg. Thanks for asking.
  Justin Scott Mon 19:04
• RRS Power Point Presentation
  Hi John
  Can you share again the links of Race Managment documents. I am planning a training session on this.
  António Negreiros Fernandes Sun 20:37
• To be a MARK or not to be
  I totaly agree with Mark Townsend’s answer. Even nothing is said about the start process in your case, it seems you are racing and RRS 31 applies and the first marks you shall not touch are the marks of the starting line. 
  Didier Greze Thu 07:52
• Rule 18.2(d)
  My summary of this thread is that 18.2(d) is similar to 18.2(e) in that it simply says you can't get a last-second overlap and expect room.
  Niko Kotsatos 26-Feb-11 14:18

Forums Leader Board

This Month