Forum: The Racing Rules of Sailing

Rule 32 "Fair or Not? Dealing with Large Wind Shifts During a Race"

Tiziano Menconi
Nationality: Italy
 During a race, can a significant wind shift (greater than 30 degrees) be valid grounds for abandoning the race under Rule 32 of the World Sailing Racing Rules of Sailing, or is it considered fair—since it affects all competitors equally—and therefore the race can continue to the finish? 
Created: Yesterday 17:39

Comments

Format:
Matthew Curtiss
"it affects all competitors equally" - I think this is likely not true for most races. Boats that couldn't fetch a mark may now be on layline and vice versa.
Created: Yesterday 18:06
Mike Forbes
Nationality: United Kingdom
The smart guys should have seen it coming (sea breeze/ weather front), and put themselves in the best position before the shift, just another part of sailing fast.  Nothing unfair.   It probably makes for a boring reach/reach race from what was a windward/leeward unless the marks are moved, but it doesn’t make it unfair.  
Created: Yesterday 18:16
Matthew Curtiss
from another thread

World Sailing Guidelines
15. Adjusting The Course To A New Wind Speed Or Direction 
15.1 Change in wind direction: 
(a) With a persistent wind shift of 10° or less the course will not be changed unless necessary to adjust for current or to provide a square run. 
(b) Between 10° and 15° consideration will be given to adjusting the course to the new wind provided that the race management team is confident that the shift is likely to persist. 
(c) With a persistent wind shift of more than 15°, the race management team will attempt to change the course to the new wind.  
(d) With a persistent wind shift of more than 45°, the race management team will consider its influence on the race.  Under these circumstances, the race management team may either change the course or abandon the race. 
(e) Frequent and violent oscillations: Under these circumstances the race management team may not be able to adjust the course sufficiently or quickly enough to maintain a race of the required standard. In this case the race may be abandoned. 
(f) Changes in current or a difference in the angle of the current relative to the wind may justify variations from these guidelines. 
Created: Yesterday 18:23
Jim Champ
Nationality: United Kingdom
I think ideally the RC would have liaised with the competitors' representatives (eg CA for a Championship) and agreed an understanding of how the sailors would like major shifts, calms and so on handled. Some fleets are quite happy with endless resets and abandonment in difficult weather, others just want to go sailing and prefer to put up with the dice tosses. If a race has turned into a procession some may prefer it to be aggressively shortened rather than abandoned. 
Created: Yesterday 18:37
P
Angelo Guarino
Forum Moderator
Nationality: United States
Tiziano .. there are a couple ways to look at your question.

First the rules question you asked .. 
RRS 32.1.
After the starting signal, the race committee may shorten the course or abandon the race:
  1. because of foul weather,
  2. because of insufficient wind making it unlikely that any boat will sail the course within the race time limit,
  3. because a mark is missing or out of position, or
  4. for any other reason directly affecting the safety or fairness of the competition,

The RC " may" .. so unless other documents state otherwise (Race Doc's, CR, Championship/Race Conditions), it is the opinion of the RC as to what is "fair".  When a committee "may" do something, it's completely their option to do something or not.  Neither decision (abandon/not-abandon) is an improper action or omission by the RC eligible for challenge in a redress hearing.

Beyond that, you can see if there are any "Conditions" set for the regatta.

Conditions for racing can be directed, with differing degree of "force", on what is necessary for the regatta.  Sometimes these have wind-shift limits within them and the actions suggested/required.  Conditions can be built into the NOR/SI for regattas of importance, the Class Rules or for Championships at different levels.
Created: Yesterday 18:37
P
Michael Butterfield
Yes the race can be abandoned, especially earlyin a race when thereis no established leader.

You do not have to abandon though. 

Created: Yesterday 19:11
Doc Sullivan
Nationality: United States
Here is part if the ILCA race management guidelines it says may not shall. 
13. Abandonment 

13.1 On the first half of the first leg, the race committee may abandon a race in the event of persistent wind shift of more than 25 degrees. After that, the race committee will let the race continue if it is able to adjust to the changed conditions.

Created: Today 01:06
P
Angelo Guarino
Forum Moderator
Nationality: United States
Doc .. are these race management guidelines embedded into the CR's or published as a separate doc?
Created: Today 11:18
Doc Sullivan
Nationality: United States
https://ilcasailing.org/rules-and-technical/race-management-policies/
Separate document. Someone asked for redress because of big shifts and did not follow guidelines. Lo and behold they are not used for redress 

RACE MANAGEMENT POLICIES

Date effective: 3rd October 2023 

Please note that these policies are guidelines for the Race Committee. These guidelines do not change the rules that apply at an event. Failure to observe these guidelines is not grounds for redress.

Created: Today 13:32
P
Angelo Guarino
Forum Moderator
Nationality: United States
Doc .. thanks. So sometimes the doc is called "Conditions", "Race Conditions", "Race Management Guide" .. etc. 

I guess one important point to make is that RRS 32 is not restricted from change in an NOR/SI by RRS 86. So, a Class can work with the OA/RC to get specific abandonment requirements in and change RRS 32.1's "may" to a "shall" under specific circumstances. 

In that case, an RC not following the rule would be an error/omission and potentially redressable. 
Created: Today 15:34
Doc Sullivan
Nationality: United States
Agree. It is a nice document to give guidance to the OA as to how the class wants to play the game. Not sure how many know it exists 
Created: Today 16:25
[You must be signed in to add a comment]
Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn more