The Racing Rules of Sailing
Member of the public witness to infringement of a rule
1. Can a member of the public make a formal protest?
2. Can a member of the public be a witness in a protest?
2. Can a member of the public be a witness in a protest?
Created: 25-Mar-11 19:57
Comments
Format:
You must be signed in to add a comment.
2. Yes. RRS 63.4(b)
2. Yes. Nothing in the rules places restrictions on who can be a witness. Appendix M3.2(c) says anyone can be a witness.
Would I be right in thinking that if a member of the public reported an incident to the PC "that may have resulted in injury or serious damage" the PC may protest the boat in spite of 69.1c?
60.1 A committee can protest a boat
60.4(b)(3) A protest from a committee is invalid if it based on a report from a person with a conflict of interest.
So, the public-person can notify a committee, give the report, and if the that person does not have a conflict of interest, the protest from that info is not invalid (if the committee decides to protest).
PS: For the protest committee, if they received a "protest" filing from John Q Public, I don't see a reason that they shouldn't treat the protest as a "report".