2018 Asian Games Sailing Competition

Protest Decisions

No. Type Race Protestor Protestees Decision Rules
01.
Protest
1 Mixed RS One - M - SGP Mixed RS One - M - KOR
KOR is DSQ in Race 1
Full Decision
RRS 10 ,14
02.
Protest
1 Laser Standard - JPN 208000 Laser Standard - MAS 214989
Protest dismissed.
Full Decision
03.
Protest
1 Open Laser 4.7 - W - KOR 214439 Open Laser 4.7 - W - JPN 193835
Heard With Protest(s): 06
JPN is DSQ in Race 1
Full Decision
RRS 15, 14
04.
Protest
1 Laser Radial - W - KOR 211531 Laser Radial - W - CHN 201213
Heard With Protest(s): 07
IND is DSQ in Race 1
Full Decision
RRS 11, 12, 14, 64.1(a)
05.
Protest
1 Protest Committee Support Person

Alexandr Denisiuc is forbidden to go out on the water until all Laser classes have completed race 3.

Laser Radial IND 195372, Laser 4.7 IND 210440 and Laser 4.7 IND 210439 were warned that if Alexandr Denisiuc commits a further breach, then may be penalized.

Full Decision
SI D6.1, SI D6.3
06.
Protest
1 Open Laser 4.7 - M - JPN Open Laser 4.7 - W - KOR
Heard With 03
07.
Protest
1 Laser Radial - W - CHN Laser Radial - W - IND
Heard With 04
08.
Request to Reopen
1 Laser Radial - Radial - IND 195372
The hearing for Cases 4 and 7 are to be reopened.
Full Decision
66
09.
Protest
1 Laser - Radial - IND 195372 Laser - Radial - CHN 201213
Protest is dismissed.
Full Decision
10.
Protest by TC
4 Technical Committee Laser - Standard - KOR 210793
Decision Complete Class rule part 2, 3(b) x, SI 15.9, WS DP Policy
11.
Request for Redress
3 49er - M - KOR KOR 515

Redress given to KOR.
KOR is to be scored in Race 3 the points equal to the average point of Race 1 and 2, rounded to the nearest tenth of a point (0.05 to be rounded upward).

Full Decision
62.1(b)
12.
Protest and Request for Redress
3 49er - M - KOR 515 49er - M - CHN 251
DSQ CHN in Race 3.
Full Decision
10, 14, 44.1(b)
13.
Request for Redress
3,4,5 49er - M - KOR 515
Redress given to KOR in Race 3 which is the average points from Races 1 and 2, rounded to the nearest tenth of a point (0.05 to be rounded upward) .
Full Decision
RRS 62.1(b) and A10
14.
Protest
5 49er - M - JPN 847 49er - M - IND IND 316
The Protest Committee permitted the withdrawal of the protest
Full Decision
15.
Protest
5 49er - M - IND 316 49er - M - JPN 847
The Protest Committee approved the request to withdraw the protest.
Full Decision