34th YAI Senior Multiclass (Ranking) National Sailing Championship 2019

Hearing Decisions

No. Type Race Initiator Respondent(s) Decision
01.
Protest by TC
pre race Technical Committee LASER RDL - OPEN - IND 551155
Rules: SI 19.2
1. Protest Upheld.

2. The penalty imposed shall be 50% of the score for DNF applied to race number 1, rounded to the nearest tenth of a point (0.05 to be rounded upward). The penalty shall be no worse than a score equal to RET or DSQ. The scores of other boats shall not be changed as a result of this penalty.

02.
Protest
3 LASER 4.7 - OPEN - IND210440 - 210441 LASER 4.7 - BU16 - IND191119 - 202231
Rules: Rule 10 and Case 50
1. Protest upheld.

2. IND 191119 DSQ in race No 3.
03.
Protest
3 LASER 4.7 - BU16 - IND 41 - 205016 LASER 4.7 - BU16 - IND 2 - 209906
Rules: RRS 15 and 14
1. Protest upheld.

2.  IND 2 DSQ in race No 3.
04.
Protest
5 LASER STD - OPEN - IND 208191 - 210454 LASER STD - OPEN - IND 211803 - 211760
Rules: RRS 18.2(e), 18.2(b)
Protest dismissed.
05.
Protest
7 470 CLASS - OPEN - IND749 - 33799 470 CLASS - OPEN - IND 31 - 33953
Request Invalid
Rules: SI16.1
Protest invalid
06.
Protest
8 470 CLASS - OPEN - IND1 - 33797 470 CLASS - OPEN - IND02 - 33829
Rules: RRS31, 44.2
1. Protest Upheld
2. IND02 is DSQ in Race 8
07.
Protest
9 470 CLASS - OPEN - IND23 - 32103 49ER - OPEN - IND316 - 1730
Request Invalid
Rules: SI16.1
1. Protest Invalid
08.
Protest
8 LASER 4.7 - OPEN - IND210440 - 210441 LASER 4.7 - BU16 - IND 71 - 209827
Rules: RRS44.2, 63.1
1. Protest Withdrawn
09.
Protest and Request to Reopen
9 LASER RDL - OPEN - IND 5037 - 11 LASER RDL - YU17 - IND201118 - 210441
Rules: RRS 11,14,18.2(b), 31, 21, 63.3(b)
1. Protest Upheld
2.  IND 201118 is DSQ in Race 9
3. Request to reopen the hearing by 2011118 is denied.
10.
Protest
11 LASER RDL - GGM - IND 47 - 157395 LASER RDL - OPEN - IND 5 - 205019
Request Invalid
Rules: RRS 61.1
Protest Invalid.
11.
Reporting of an Incident
Organizational Authority
No further action needed.
12.
Protest
10 RS:X - OPEN - IND1 - NP12RSX12030091 RSX - 69
Rules: RRS 63.1
Permission to withdraw protest granted as per RRS 63.1.
13.
Protest and Request for Redress
10 LASER RDL - OPEN - IND 72 - 205014
Rules: RRS 62.1(b)
IND 72's request for redress is granted. IND 72 is to be scored in race 10 points equal to the average, rounded to the nearest tenth of a point (0.05 to be rounded upward), of her points in all races sailed in the series, except race 10. This  shall not change the score of the other boats.
14.
Protest
12 LASER 4.7 - BU16 - IND21044 - 210440 LASER 4.7 - BU16 - IND 9 - 208194
Rules: RRS 11, 14
IND 9 is DSQ in race No12
15.
Protest
11 LASER 4.7 - BU16 - IND191119 - 202231 LASER 4.7 - OPEN - IND210440 - 210441
Rules: No rules broken
Protest Dismissed.