Singapore National Sailing Championships 2019

Hearing Decisions

No. Type Race Initiator Respondent(s) Decision
12. Request for Redress 1,2,4 Optimist Gold - MYA278 Race Committee
Rules: RRS62.1(a)
MYA278 to be scored in Races 1,2, and 4 positions  RDG40th, RDG40th and RDG49th respectively and no other boats are to be affected by these redress score given. 
    11. Protest by RC 7 Optimist Gold - SGP3279 Race Committee
    Rules: No rules broken
    Protest is dismissed.
      10. Protest 9 29er - SGP1540 29er - SGP2446
      Rules: RRS63.1
      Protest allowed to be withdrawn
        09. Protest 12 29er - SGP2869 29er - SGP1539
        Rules: RRS13
        SGP1539 is DSQ in Race 12
          08. Protest by RC 5 Race Committee Optimist Gold - 9
          Request Invalid
          Rules: RRS61.3, SI16.3
          Protest is invalid
            07. Protest by RC 5 Race Committee Optimist Gold - 3153
            Request Invalid
            Rules: RRS63.1 , SI16.3
            Protest is invalid
              06. Protest by RC 5 Race Committee Optimist Gold - 86
              Request Invalid
              Rules: RRS63.1, SI 16.3
              Protest is invalid
                05. Protest by RC 5 Race Committee Optimist - 277
                Request Invalid
                Rules: RRS61.3, SI16.3
                Protest Invalid
                  04. Protest 6 Laser 4.7 - 214242 Laser 4.7 - 126750
                  Rules: RRS18.2(b), RRS14
                  214242 is DSQ in Race 6
                    03. Protest 5 29er - SGP1539 29er - SGP2869
                    Rules: RRS11, RRS14, App T1, RRS44.3(c)
                    1. The penalty imposed on SGP2869 shall be 30% of the score for DNF applied to race number 5, rounded to the nearest tenth of a point (0.05 to be rounded upward). The penalty shall be no worse than a score equal to DNF. The scores of other boats shall not be changed as a result of this penalty.
                      02. Protest by PC 5 Protest Committee Optimist Gold - Yellow - MYA 277
                      Rules: SI11.4, Discretionary Penalty Guide
                      1. The penalty imposed on MYA277 shall be 5% of the score for DNF applied to race number 5 , rounded to the nearest tenth of a point (0.05 to be rounded upward). The penalty shall be no worse than a score equal to RET or DSQ. The scores of other boats shall not be changed as a result of this penalty.
                        01. Protest by PC 5 Protest Committee Optimist Gold - Yellow - HKG313
                        Rules: SI11.4, Discretionary Penalty Guide
                        1. The penalty imposed on HKG313 shall be 5% of the score for DNF applied to race number 5 , rounded to the nearest tenth of a point (0.05 to be rounded upward). The penalty shall be no worse than a score equal to RET or DSQ. The scores of other boats shall not be changed as a result of this penalty.