Moth World Championship e Pre Worlds - Italian Series

Official Notice Board

Hearing Decisions

No. Type Race Initiator Respondent(s) Decision
15. Request for Redress 13 Moth - NZL 4744
Heard With: 14
14. Request for Redress 13 Moth - NZL 4744
Heard With Protest(s): 13, 15
Rules: 62.1(b), 63.3(b)
Redress is given to NZL 4744. NZL 4744 is to be scored in race number 13 points equal to the average, rounded to the nearest tenth of a point (0.05 to be rounded upward), of her points in all races sailed in the final series, except race 13. This shall not be worse than her finishing position in the race. No other boat’s score shall change.

13. Request for Redress 13 Moth - NZL 4744
Heard With: 14
12. Protest 13 Moth - NZL 4744 Moth - FRA 4775 - GROUPE REEL
Rules: 10, 14
FRA 4775 is DSQ in race number 13.

11. Protest 10 Moth - ESP 4323 - COCó Moth - SUI 4782 - -VAMAVA
Rules: 11, 14, 64.2(b)
Protest Upheld, no further penalty.

10. Protest 10 Moth - Blue - SUI 4782 - -VAMAVA Moth - Blue - ESP 4323 - COCó
The protest committee allows the request for redress to be withdrawn.

09. Request to Reopen and Request for Redress 7 Moth - GER 4668 - ALFEA Moth - ITA 4588
Reopening not granted 
08. Reopening by PC 7 Protest Committee Moth - ITA 4448
Moth - GBR 4823 - FOMO
Rules: 18.2 (b)
The Protest is Dismissed.
Redress is not given.

07. Request to Reopen 7 moth - gold fleet - ITA 4448 moth - gold fleet - gbr 4823
Rules: 63.3(b)
Hearing number 3 will be reopened.

06. Request for Redress 9 Moth - Gold - GBR 4817 Support Person -
Request Invalid
05. Protest and Request for Redress 7 Moth - GER 4668 - ALFEA Moth - ITA 4588
Rules: RRS 10, 14
The Protest is Dismissed

04. Protest and Request for Redress 9 Moth - Gold - GBR 4823 - FOMO Moth - Gold - ITA 4448
Rules: 10, 62.1(b)
Protest Upheld. ITA 4448 took the applicable penalty and is not further penalized.

GBR 4823's request for redress is granted. GBR 4823 is to be scored in race 9 points equal to the average, rounded to the nearest tenth of a point (0.05 to be rounded upward), of her points in all races except races 7 and 8. This shall not change the score of the other boats. However, more than half GBR 4823's race scores in this series must be based on her finishing position in races she starts, and any grant of redress in excess of this amount shall not be applied to the boat's score.

03. Protest and Request for Redress 7 Moth - Gold - GBR 4823 - FOMO Moth - Gold - ITA 4448
Rules: 18.2 (b), 62.1 (b)
ITA 4448 is DSQ in race 7.

GBR 4823's request for redress is granted. GBR 4823 is to be scored in race 8 points equal to the average, rounded to the nearest tenth of a point (0.05 to be rounded upward), of her points in all races of the final series except race 7. 
This shall not change the score of the other boats. 
However, more than half GBR 4823 race scores in the final series must be based on her finishing position in races she starts, and any grant of redress in excess of this amount shall not be applied to the boat's score.

02. Protest by TC 6 Technical Committee Moth - GBR 4826
GBR 4826 a DPI given 10 points to be added to her finishing position in Race 6
01. Request for Redress 1 Moth - ARG 4810 - LöWE
Request Invalid
Rules: RRS 61.3, 62.1, 63.5
Request for redress is invalid