Kiyoshi Study

Online Notice Board

Hearing Decisions

No. Type Race Initiator Respondent(s) Decision
14. Request for Redress 8 25ft - PW 25ft - PL
Rules: rule 60.5(b)(1)
PWの救済要求は拒否する。rule 60.5(b)(1)
13. Protest 7 snipe - A snipe - B
Rules: Rule 20.2(b) , 20.1(b), 20.2(c)
Both boats A and B are disqualified. Boat A broke rule 20.1(b), Room to Tack at an Obstruction; Hailing. Boat B broke rule 20.2(b), Room to Tack at an Obstruction; Responding.
12. Protest 6 snipe - B snipe - A
Rules: RRS 10
A is penalized for breaking rule 10, On Opposite Tacks. Aに規則10(反対タック)の違反によりペナルティを課す。
11. Protest 6 snipe - B snipe - A
Rules: RRS 18.2(a)(2)
B’s protest is disallowed. Bの抗議を却下する。B complied with her obligation to give A mark-room under rule 18.2(a)(2).
10. Protest 6 snipe - SO snipe - PI
Rules: RRS 18.2(a)
Boat SO’s protest is disallowed;  Neither boat is penalized. 
09. Protest 6 snipe - SA snipe - SB
Rules: Rule 18.2(a)(2)
Boat SA is disqualified for breaking rule 18.2(a)(2), Giving Mark-Room.
08. Protest 3 snipe - A snipe - C
Rules: The definition Clear Astern and Clear Ahead
Disallow A’s protest. A was required to give both B and C mark-room under rule 18.2(a)(1)
07. Protest 3 snipe - PB snipe - PA
Rules: 18.2(e), 18.2(a)
Disallow PB’s protest. there is reasonable doubt that a boat obtained an overlap in time
06. Protest 3 25ft - SI 25ft - PO
Rules: rrs 18.2 (a)(1)
Penalize PO for breaking rule 18.2(a)(1), Giving Mark-Room. When SI reaches the zone, SI and PO are overlapped. Therefore, PO is required to give SI mark- room under rule 18.2(a)(1). 
05. Protest 3 snipe - SO snipe - PI
Rules: rrs18.2a1
PIにマークルームを与えなかったSOを失格とする。PIがゾーンに到達したとき、両艇はオーバーラップしていた。
04. Protest 1 snipe - P snipe - S
Rules: rrs 63.5
このインシデントにおいて、Sにプロパーコースを帆走することを義務付ける規則はない。
03. Protest 1 snipe - WO snipe - LI
WO 艇は LI 艇にマークルームを与えることができた。
02. Protest 1 snipe - LO snipe - WI
外側の艇LOは、外側の艇WIが LOとレース委員会艇の間を通過するためのルームを与えた。

01. Protest
    1 snipe - Y snipe - X
    Rules: rrs31, rrs42
    Protest is disallowed
    抗議を却下する。